When it comes to award shows, celebrities typically choose to go the full nine yards in terms of preparation, hiring makeup artists and hair stylists to craft their perfect look for the night out. Even the minimalist, no-makeup makeup look (like Kim Kardashian’s at the MTV Video Music Awards) takes hordes of makeup products and skin care prep just to create the impression “I woke up like this.” So it’s no wonder the Internet went absolutely crazy (in both a good way and bad) over the fact that Alicia Keys showed up without a single dab of makeup on her face for the VMAs on Sunday.